“We really need you, Banderа’s scum...”: The space of “heroes” and meanings in the play by "Glory to the Heroes" by Pavlo Arie

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.28925/2412-2475.2024.24.2

Keywords:

drama, war of memories, transgenerational trauma, social wounds, civic identity, contemporary theater

Abstract

The article analyses Pavel Arie’s play “Glory to the Heroes” in the context of its theatrical versions and analytical and critical reception from the standpoint of the “war of memories” and “social wounds.” The perception of the characters and the ‘personal truths’ they represent in this dramatic text has been significantly transformed since it was written and the time it is viewed against the backdrop of almost three years of full-scale Russian war in Ukraine and more than a decade of Russian aggression. The  deliberate caution of both the playwright himself and his theatrical interpreters (Stas Zhirkov, Oleksa Kravchuk, Viacheslav Zhyla, Anatoliy Levchenko, Alla Sokolenko) in working with the semantic field of Ukrainian civic identity is indicative, the desire to voice the existence of different historical memories in contemporary Ukraine, but at the same time demonstrate the absence of a  search for  their convergence, which is camouflaged under the intention to go beyond “politics” and pay special attention to the “humanity” of the characters, regardless of which political camp each of them belongs to. As a result, there is not a single “exemplary human” figure in the play, and the unresolved problems of the confrontation between the elderly “political” antagonists are inherited by their children and grandchildren and cement new transgenerational personal and social traumas. In  the  ending, it  seems that physical death seems to reconcile the irreconcilable enemies in life, as they walk side by side in the postmortem without weapons. At the same time, the death of both characters leaves all the questions raised in the play open, the transgenerational wounds unhealed, and the fighters for Ukrainian independence, who were stigmatized by the Soviet regime, unrehabilitated.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Arie, P. (2015). Baba Prisia ta inshi heroi [Grandma Prisia and Other Heroes]. Brustury: Dyskursus, 275 p. [in Ukrainian].

Babenko, O. (2016). Rezhyser Oleksii Kravchuk: «Ideolohiia, yaka ne nese povahy i liubovi, peretvoriuie liudynu u monstra» [Director Oleksiy Kravchuk: “Ideology that does not bring respect and love, turns a person into a monster”]. ARTarea [in Ukrainian].

https://art-area.com.ua/2016/01/rezhiser-oleksiy-kravchuk-ideologiya-yaka-ne-nese-povagi-i-lyubovi-peretvoryuye-lyudinu-u-monstra

British Council in Ukraine. (2017). Pavlo Arie: «Brytanska Rada — tse mozhlyvist vidkryvaty dveri, yaki nikoly ne vidkryvalysia» [Pavlo Arie: “The British Council is an opportunity to open doors that have never been opened before”]. [in Ukrainian].

https://www.britishcouncil.org.ua/about/british-council-ukraine/25-years/arie

Bublyk, M. (2018, October 30). Oleksii Kravchuk, teatralnyi rezhyser: Shche neskoro, ale vse vernetsia v Ukrainu. Prosto treba vesty borotbu ne tilky zbroieiu [Oleksiy Kravchuk, theater director: “Not soon, but everything will return to Ukraine. You just have to fight not only with weapons”]. Ukrinform [in Ukrainian].

https://www.ukrinform.ua/rubric-regions/2569291-oleksij-kravcuk-teatralnij-reziser.html

Fedoliak, I. (2016, March 18). Slava stalkeram [Glory to the Stalkers]. Zbruč [in Ukrainian]. https://zbruc.eu/node/49102

Holovnenko, A. (2016, February 03). Ponavisiat medali, krychatymut: “Slava!” [Medals will be hung up, they will shout: “Glory!”]. Teatre [in Ukrainian].

https://teatre.com.ua/review/onavisjat-medali-krychatymut-lava-

Gornostai, P. (2023). Psykholohiia kolektyvnykh travm [Psychology of Collective Traumas]. Monograph, Kropyvnytskyi: Imeks-LTD [in Ukrainian].

Hostieva, A. (2016, March 08). «Treba prosto bachyty odyn odnoho»: lvivian zaproshuiut na istorychni vystavy [“We just need to see each other”: Lviv residents are invited to historical performances]. Tvoie misto [in Ukrainian]. https://tvoemisto.tv/news/treba_prosto_bachyty_odyn_odnogo_lvivyan_zaproshuyut_na_istorychni_vystavy_76750.html

Hrabska, A. (2017, May 05). Pavlo Arie: Na Zakhodi khochut bachyty ukrainskyi teatr [Pavlo Arie: In the West, they want to see Ukrainian theatre]. Deutsche Welle [in Ukrainian].

https://www.dw.com/uk/павло-арє-на-заході-вже-ніхто-не-асоціює-український-театр-із-ро-сійським/a-38709498

Ilkiv, V. (2016, June 22). Komediia “Slava Heroiam”: diahnostyka “viiny” [Comedy “Glory to Heroes”: Diagnosis of “war”]. Ukraina Moloda, 078 [in Ukrainian].

https://www.umoloda.kiev.ua/number/3010/164/100514/

Kataieva, M. (2016, January 21). Zavtra v stolytsi prezentuiut vystavu pro veteraniv “Slava heroiam” [Tomorrow in the capital, a play about veterans “Glory to heroes” will be presented]. Vechirnii Kyiv [in Ukrainian]. https://vechirniy.kyiv.ua/news/3137/

Komitet z Natsionalnoi premii Ukrainy imeni Tarasa Shevchenka. (2021). Vystava “Slava Heroiam” Kyivskoho akademichnoho teatru “Zoloti vorota” [Performance “Glory to the Heroes” of Kyiv Academic Theatre “Golden Gate”]. Official website [in Ukrainian].

https://knpu.gov.ua/archive/vistava-slava-gerojam-kiivskogo-akademichnogo-teatru-zoloti-vorota

Libertango (Slava heroiam). (2016). [in Ukrainian].

https://theatre.com.ua/libertango-slava-geroyam

Lypkіvska, H. (2014, June 18). Nazad u… maibutnie. Aktualna ukrainska drama na prykladi Lvivskoho teatru im. Lesia Kurbasа [Back to… the Future. Current Ukrainian drama based on the example of Les Kurbas Lviv Theatre]. Den, 110 [in Ukrainian].

https://day.kyiv.ua/article/kultura/nazad-u-maybutnye

Miroshnychenko, N. (2023). Novitnia ukrainska drama yak diahnostychna model suspilnykh zmin ostannoi rosiisko-ukrainskoi viiny [The Ukrainian Drama as a Diagnostic Model of the Last Russian-Ukrainian War]. Kurbasivski chytannia, 18, 34–52.

Na mezhi pravdy i brekhni: vystava “Slava heroiam” vidkryla festyval “Veresnevi samotsvity”.(2016, September 22). [On the border between truth and lies: the performance “Glory to the heroes” opened the “September Gems” festival]. Persha electronna hazeta [in Ukrainian].

https://persha.kr.ua/article/93089-na-mezhi-pravdy-i-brehni-vystava-slava-geroyam-vidkryla-festyval-veresnevi-samotsvity

Nepokora, I. (2015, May 29). Arie Pavlo: Use pochynaietsia z istorii [Arye Pavlo: Everything begins with a story] [Interview]. Interview from Ukraine [in Ukrainian].

https://rozmova.wordpress.com/2015/06/13/pavlo-are

Nikitina, Yu. (2016, September 17). Trahikomediiu Pavla Arie ternopoliany zustrily shalenymy opleskamy [Ternopil Residents Greeted Pavlo Arie’s Tragicomedy with a Standing Ovation]. 20 khvylyn [in Ukrainian].

https://te.20minut.ua/Kult-podii/tragikomediyu-pavla-are-ternopolyani-zustrili-shalenimi-opleskami-10544632.html

Nitsoi, L. (2017, November 11). Vystava “Slava heroiam”: koly vsi hliadachi nache pid hipnozom [The Performance “Glory to the Heroes”: When all the audience seems to be under hypnosis]. Hlavkom [in Ukrainian].

https://glavcom.ua/columns/lnicoi/vistava-slava-geroyam-450312.html

Nizhynskyi dramatychnyi teatr zaproshuie na premieru novoi vystavy. (2022, November 11).[Nizhyn Drama Theater Invites to the Premiere of a New Play]. Ніжин.City. [in Ukrainian]. https://nizhyn.city/articles/249267/nizhinskij-dramatichnij-teatr-zaproshuye-na-premyeru-novoi-vistavi

Oliinyk, Ye. (2016, January 21). U Kyievi pokazhut vystavu pro veteraniv Chervonoi armii y UPA [A Play about Veterans of the Red Army and the UPA will be shown in Kyiv]. Radio Svoboda. https://www.radiosvoboda.org/a/27502189.html

Ovsiiuk, O. (2018). Kontseptualni pidkhody do interpretatsii podii Druhoi svitovoi viiny v dobu postmodernizmu [Conceptual Approaches to the Interpretation of the Events of the Second World War in the Era of Postmodernism]. In M. Hrymych (Ed.). Antropolohiia transformatsii: ukrainske suspilstvo v umovakh hlobalizatsii ta mizhkulturnoi vzaiemodii (pp. 52–66). Kyiv: Duliby [in Ukrainian].

Protasova, A. (2015). Baba Prisia ta inshi heroi [review]. Krytyka, 11–12(217–218), 25 [in Ukrainian].

Sadovska, H. (2016, October 5). Yak “ne svoi” ukraintsi svoimy staly [How “not their own” Ukrainians became their own]. Vilne zhyttia [in Ukrainian].

https://vilne.org.ua/2016/10/yak-ne-svoyi-ukrayintsi-svoyimy-staly

Sahal, O. (2016, September 21). Festyval vysokykh potriasin [Festival of High Upheavals]. NOVA Ternopilska hazeta [in Ukrainian].

https://nova.te.ua/statti/festyval-vysokyh-potryasin

Semchuk, K. (2018, November 4). Ukraina na try teatry, try piesy [Ukraine for three theaters, three plays]. Nashe slovo, 44 [in Ukrainian].

https://nasze-slowo.pl/ukraina-na-tri-teatri-tri-p-iesi

Semeniak, V. (2016, September 18). Chomu nam tak pohano zhyvetsia? Pro tse znaie ternopilskyi rezhyser Viacheslav Zhyla [Why do we live so badly? Ternopil director Vyacheslav Zhila knows about this]. TeNews [in Ukrainian].

https://tenews.org.ua/post/show/chomu_nam_tak_pogano_zhivet_sya-_pro_ce_znae_ternopil_s_ kiy_rezhiser_v-yacheslav_zhila

Senyshyn, O. (2016, March 4). Kyiv ta Frankivsk vezut do Lvova “Stalkery” ta “Slava heroiam” [Kyiv and Frankivsk bring the performances “Stalkers” and “Glory to heroes” to Lviv]. ZAXID.NET [in Ukrainian].

https://zaxid.net/kiyiv_ta_frankivsk_vezut_do_lvova_vistavi_stalkeri_ta_slava_geroyam_n1384800

Shchokan, H. (2024, February 29). “Dosi ne vpevnena, chy mozhna vzhe hovoryty pro viinu ta yak same” [“I’m still not sure if it’s possible to talk about the war and how”]. Gazeta.ua [in Ukrainian].

https://gazeta.ua/articles/culture-journal/_dosi-ne-vpevnena-chi-mozhna-vzhe-govoriti-pro-vijnu-ta-yak-same/1172169

Shot, M. (2016, December 10). Rezhyser, dramaturh, khudozhnyk Pavlo Arie: “Dlia mene shchastia, shcho za moieiu piesoiu rezhyser Volodymyr Tykhyi vziavsia znimaty kinostrichku ‘Brama’” [Director, dramatist, artist Pavlo Arie: “I am lucky that director Volodymyr Tykhi undertook to shoot the film ‘Brama’ based on my play”]. Uriadovyi kurier [in Ukrainian].

https://ukurier.gov.ua/uk/articles/rezhiser-dramaturg-hudozhnik-pavlo-arye-dlya-mene-

Shpuliar, U. (2016, January 15). Pavlo Arie z premieroiu “Slava Heroiam” na stseni lvivskoho teatru [Pavlo Arie with the premiere of “Glory to Heroes” on the stage of the Lviv theater]. Lviv City Council. Official website [in Ukrainian].

https://city-adm.lviv.ua/news/culture/229445-pavlo-ar-ie-z-prem-ieroiu-slava-heroiam-na-stseni-lvivskoho-teatru

Skuba, V. (2016). Vidbulasia premiera vystavy “Slava Heroiam” [The premiere of the performance “Glory to Heroes” took place]. Official website of UINM [in Ukrainian].

https://old.uinp.gov.ua/news/vidbulasya-prem-era-vistavi-slava-geroyam

Slava heroiam. (2016). [Glory to the Heroes]. Ivano-Frankivskyi dramteatr [in Ukrainian]. http://www.dramteatr.if.ua/show/slava-geroyam

Slava Heroiam po-ternopilsky. (2016, September 22). [Glory to the Heroes in the Ternopil style]. Yabluchko [in Ukrainian].

http://yabluchko.com.ua/news/1849/60/slava-geroyam-po-ternop-lski

Slava heroiam. Premiera. (2022). [“Glory to the Heroes”. Premiere]. Nizhynskyi akademichnyi ukrainskyi dramatychnyi teatr imeni Mykhaila Kotsiubynskoho [in Ukrainian].

https://www.nezhin-dram.in.ua/repertuar/komediini-vystavy/528-slava-heroiam.html

Slava heroiam? (2024). [Glory to the Heroes?]. Teatr Lesi [in Ukrainian].

https://teatrlesi.lviv.ua/event/slava-heroiam

“Slava heroiam” — tse provokatsiia. (2016, February 11). [“Glory to the Heroes” as a provocation]. Halytskyi korespondent [in Ukrainian].

https://gk-press.if.ua/slava-geroyam-tse-provokatsiya

Slavinska, I., & Proskurnia, S. (2020, November 19). U Moskvi vin postavyv piesu ukrainskoiu movoiu, yii dosi hraiut — Serhii Proskurnia pro Romana Viktiuka [In Moscow, he staged a play in Ukrainian, it is still performed — Serhiy Proskurnya about Roman Viktyuk]. Hromadske radio [in Ukrainian].

https://hromadske.radio/podcasts/hromadska-hvylya/u-moskvi-vin-postavyv-p-iesu-pavla-ar-ie-ukrains-koiu-movoiu-ii-dosi-hraiut-serhiy-proskurnia-pro-romana-viktiuka

Slipchenko, K. (2014, October 7). U teatri Romana Viktiuka postavyly piesu Pavla Arie [A play by Pavel Arie was staged at the Roman Viktyuk theater]. ZAXID.NET [in Ukrainian].

https://zaxid.net/u_teatri_romana_viktyuka_postavili_pyesu_pavla_arye_n1325147

Stiazhkina, O. (2020). Druha svitova viina v zhytti ta smerti ukraintsiv: sproba nalashtuvannia metodolohichnoi optyky [The Second World War in the Life and Death of Ukrainians: An attempt to adjust methodological optics]. In H. Boriak et al (Eds.). Academia. Terra Historiae. Studii na poshanu Valeriia Smoliia: Vol. 1. Prostory istoriï (pp. 587–607). Kyiv: In-t istorii Ukrainy Natsionalnoi akademii nauk Ukrainy, DU “Instytut vsesvitnoi istorii Natsionalnoi akademii nauk Ukrainy” [in Ukrainian].

Todoriuk, D. (2016, March 23). Hlyboki ta boliuchi pytannia vystavy “Slava heroiam!” [Deep and Painful Questions of the Play “Glory to the Heroes!”]. Oboz.ua [in Ukrainian].

https://www.obozrevatel.com/blogs/92861-moi-rekomendatsii-gliboki-i-bolyuchi-pitannya-vistavi-slava-geroyam.htm

Troian, S., & Kyrydon, A. (2016). “Viiny pamiatei” u vymiri informatsiinoho protystoiannia [“War memory” in the measurement of the information confrontation]. Ukraina — Europa — Svit, 18, 40–45 [in Ukrainian].

Troshchynska, Т. (2015, December 23). My ne khochemo nikoho prymiriaty, teatr ne mozhe zminyty zhyttia, — S. Zhyrkov [We don’t want to reconcile anyone, the theatre cannot change life, —S. Zhyrkov]. Hromadske radio [in Ukrainian].

https://hromadske.radio/podcasts/kyiv-donbas/my-ne-hochemo-nikogo-prymyryaty-teatr-ne-mozhe-zminyty-zhyttya-s-zhyrkov

Turii, R. (2016, February 21). Vid klounady do trahedii: frankivtsiam pokazaly vystavu pro voiaka UPA ta veterana Radianskoi armii [From Clowning to Tragedy: Ivano-Frankivsk residents were shown a play about a UPA soldier and a veteran of the Soviet Army]. Galka [in Ukrainian].

https://galka.if.ua/vid-klounadi-do-tragediyi-ivanofrankivtsyam-pokazali-vistavu-pro-voyaka-upa-ta-veterana-radyanskoyi-armiyi-foto

Tyden, N. (2014, October 27). Roman Viktiuk postavyv u Moskvi avanhardnu ukrainsku piesu na “movi” [Roman Viktyuk staged an avant-garde Ukrainian play in “mova” in Moscow]. ZN.UA [in Ukrainian]. https://zn.ua/ukr/CULTURE/roman-viktyuk-postaviv-u-moskvi-avangardnu-ukrayinsku-p-yesu-na-movi-155002_.html

U Kyievi prezentuvaly teatralnyi proekt “Slava heroiam”. (2016, Yanuary 20). [Theatrical project “Glory to the Heroes” was presented in Kyiv]. Ukrainskii pohliad [in Ukrainian].

https://ukrpohliad.org/news/u-kyyevi-prezentuvaly-teatralnyj-proekt-slava-geroyam.html

U Lvivskomu dramteatri imeni Lesi Ukrainky vidbudetsia premiera vystavy “Slava Heroiam”.(2016, January 31). [The premiere of the play “Glory to Heroes” will take place at the Lviv Drama Theater named after Lesya Ukrainka]. Dailylviv.com [in Ukrainian].

https://dailylviv.com/news/kultura/u-lvivskomu-dramteatri-imeni-lesi-ukrayinky-vidbudetsya-premiera-vystavy-slava-heroyam-27822

Ukaz Prezydenta Ukrainy. (2006, October 14). #879/2006 Pro vsebichne vyvchennia ta obiektyvne vysvitlennia diialnosti ukrainskoho vyzvolnoho rukhu ta spryiannia protsesu natsionalnoho prymyrennia [Decree of the President of Ukraine “On Comprehensive Study and Objective Coverage of the Activities of the Ukrainian. Liberation Movement and Promotion of the Process of National Reconciliation”]. Official website [in Ukrainian].

https://www.president.gov.ua/documents/8792006-4950

Ukaz Prezydenta Ukrainy. (2010, January 28). #75/2010 Pro vshanuvannia uchasnykiv borotby za nezalezhnist Ukrainy u XX stolitti [Decree of the President of Ukraine “On Honoring the Participants of the Struggle for the Independence of Ukraine in the 20th century]. Official website [in Ukrainian]. https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/75/2010#Text

Verhelis, O. (2015). Zhyttia dramy [A Life of Drama]. In P. Arie (Aut.), Baba Prisia ta inshi heroi (pp. 5–10). Brustury: Dyskursus [in Ukrainian].

Verhelis, O. (2016, October 01). Pidvisheni liudy [Hanged People]. ZN.UA [in Ukrainian]. https://zn.ua/ukr/ART/pidvisheni-lyudi-_.html

Veselovska, H. (2016, March 2). Peremahaiuchy realnist [Defeating Reality]. Den [in Ukrainian]. https://day.kyiv.ua/article/kultura/peremahayuchy-realnist

Visych, O. (2018). Postmoderna metadramа Pavla Arie “Liudyna v pidvishenomu stani” [The Postmodern Metadrama “The Man in a State of Elevation” by Pavlo Arie]. Visnyk Lvivskoho universytetu. Seriia filolohichna, 67(2), 279–285 [in Ukrainian].

Vynnychenko, S. (2016, April 4). Preparovana “Slava heroiam” [Prepared “Glory to the Heroes”]. Theatrical fishing [in Ukrainian].

http://www.t-fishing.co.ua/plays/preparovana_slava_heroyam

Vyshnia, O. (2014, June 12). Pavlo Arie: Teatr mozhe buty bez tabu [Pavlo Arie: Theater can be without taboos]. Varianty [in Ukrainian].

https://varianty.lviv.ua/publikatsiyi/pavlo-arie-teatr-mozhe-buty-bez-tabu

Yakovlenko, K. (2014, February 22). “Potribno vesty kulturnyi dialoh z Rosiieiu na yikhnii terytorii”. Pavlo Arie pro premieru svoiei piesy ta tendentsii u suchasnii dramaturhii [“It is necessary to conduct a cultural dialogue with Russia on their territory”. Pavlo Arie about the premiere of his play and trends in modern drama]. Den, 197 [in Ukrainian].

https://day.kyiv.ua/article/kultura/potribno-vesty-kulturnyy-dialoh-z-rosiyeyu-na-yikhniy-terytoriyi

Yakubych, S. (2016). Vystava “Slava Heroiam”: teatralnyi pohliad na ukrainski realii [The Performance “Glory to Heroes”: A theatrical view of Ukrainian realities]. ARTarea [in Ukrainian]. https://art-area.com.ua/2016/07/vistava-slava-geroyam-teatralniy-poglyad-na-ukrayinski-realiyi

Yuhan, N. (2019). Formuvannia natsionalnoi identychnosti ukrainskoho suspilstva zasobamy teatru [Formation of the National Identity of the Ukrainian Society by Means of Theater]. Visnyk Natsionalnoi akademii kerivnykh kadriv kultury i mystetstv, 2, 341–345 [in Ukrainian].

Zeleniuk, M. (2017). Literaturni mihratsii. Istoriia dramaturha Pavla Arie [Literary Migrations. The Story of the Playwright Pavlo Arie]. Lviv BookForum [in Ukrainian].

https://bookforum.ua/p/literaturni-migratsiyi-istoriya-dramaturga-pavla-ar-ye

Downloads


Abstract views: 57

Published

30.12.2024

How to Cite

Bondareva, O. (2024). “We really need you, Banderа’s scum.”: The space of “heroes” and meanings in the play by "Glory to the Heroes" by Pavlo Arie. LITERARY PROCESS: Methodology, Names, Trends, (24), 17–39. https://doi.org/10.28925/2412-2475.2024.24.2

Issue

Section

Sientifical articles